Word order in subordinate clauses in English

by Jakub Marian

Tip: Are you a non-native English speaker? I have just finished creating a Web App for people who enjoy learning by reading. Make sure to check it out; there's a lot of free content.

Word order differs between questions and subordinate clauses (i.e. sentences beginning like “the place where …”, “the time when …”, “the man who …”). Clauses beginning with “why”, “where”, “when”, etc., are often misleading because they look like questions but aren’t.

The rule here is that word order in subordinate clauses is exactly the same as in ordinary (non-question) sentences, e.g.:

I don’t know why someone does something.
I don’t know why someone is doing something.

(notice that “does” and “is doing” comes after “someone”). For example:

correct I don’t know why she did it.
wrong I don’t know why did she do it.
correct I don’t know why she has done it.
wrong I don’t know why has she done it.

The same would happen in a question:

correct Do you know why she did it?
wrong Do you know why did she do it?
correct Do you know why she is doing that?
wrong Do you know why is she doing that?

But isn’t word order different in questions? Yes, but the question is “Do you know …?”. The part “why she did it” is a subordinate clause, no matter what comes before it. People tend to make mistakes especially after “who” and “what”:

correct Do you know who he is?
wrong Do you know who is he?

The structure is slightly different if there is no subject in the subordinate clause, i.e. when we actually ask about the subject:

Do you know who did it?
Since it has the same as the structure as the corresponding question, it shouldn’t pose any problems.

By the way, have you already seen my brand new web app for non-native speakers of English? It's based on reading texts and learning by having all meanings, pronunciations, grammar forms etc. easily accessible. It looks like this:

0